South China Sea Dispute: Territorial Tensions

  Mar 23, 2024

South China Sea Dispute

1. What is the South China Sea dispute about?
The South China Sea dispute involves territorial and maritime claims over the South China Sea's islands, reefs, and waters. Several countries, including China, the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei, and Taiwan, have overlapping claims. The dispute is not only about sovereignty but also about strategic control, access to resources, and freedom of navigation.

2. Why is the South China Sea important?
The South China Sea is crucial for several reasons: it's one of the world's busiest maritime trade routes, with a significant portion of global shipping passing through it; it's believed to hold vast reserves of oil and gas; and it has rich fishing grounds. Additionally, its strategic location makes it a key area for military dominance in the Asia-Pacific region.

3. What is China's Nine-Dash Line?
China's Nine-Dash Line is a demarcation line used by China to claim sovereignty over most of the South China Sea. This claim, depicted as nine dashes on Chinese maps, encompasses an area that overlaps with the maritime zones claimed by other countries. The legality of the Nine-Dash Line is widely disputed by other nations and has been invalidated by an international tribunal under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

4. What was the 2016 tribunal ruling about?
In 2016, an arbitral tribunal constituted under UNCLOS ruled against China's claims in the South China Sea, particularly invalidating the Nine-Dash Line's legal basis. The tribunal found that China's activities in the region had violated the Philippines' sovereign rights in its exclusive economic zone (EEZ). China has rejected the ruling, stating it does not recognize the tribunal's jurisdiction.

5. How has the international community responded to the South China Sea dispute?
The international community, including the United States and the European Union, has expressed concerns over the militarization of the South China Sea and the potential threat to freedom of navigation and overflight. While not taking a position on the territorial disputes, the US conducts freedom of navigation operations (FONOPs) to challenge what it sees as excessive maritime claims. The dispute remains a point of contention in China's relations with its neighbors and the broader international community.

6. What are the potential risks of the dispute?
The primary risks include the possibility of military confrontation, either by accident or through escalation of tensions. The dispute also undermines regional stability and economic development, complicates international diplomatic relations, and poses challenges to the principle of free navigation in international waters.

7. What efforts are being made to resolve the dispute?
Efforts to resolve the dispute have included bilateral and multilateral talks, ASEAN-led initiatives, and attempts to negotiate a Code of Conduct in the South China Sea. However, progress has been slow, and tensions continue to flare periodically, reflecting the complex nature of the dispute and the strategic interests involved.

The Significance of the Second Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea Dispute

1. What is the Second Thomas Shoal?
The Second Thomas Shoal, known in the Philippines as Ayungin Shoal, is a submerged reef in the Spratly Islands of the South China Sea. It has been a focal point of territorial disputes, especially between China and the Philippines. The shoal is strategically significant due to its location in disputed waters and its proximity to other key areas in the South China Sea.

2. Why is the Second Thomas Shoal contentious?
The contention over the Second Thomas Shoal stems from overlapping territorial claims by China, which refers to it within its "Nine-Dash Line," and the Philippines, which considers it part of its continental shelf and within its 200-nautical-mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ). The Philippines has stationed a small military garrison on the BRP Sierra Madre, a warship deliberately grounded on the shoal in 1999 to assert its claim.

3. How does the Second Thomas Shoal impact the South China Sea dispute?
The Second Thomas Shoal is emblematic of the broader South China Sea dispute, highlighting the challenges of sovereignty, access to resources, and strategic dominance in the region. Incidents around the shoal, such as attempts to resupply the Philippine garrison being blocked or harassed by Chinese vessels, have heightened tensions and drawn international attention to the dispute.

4. What are the implications of the dispute over the Second Thomas Shoal?
Disputes over the Second Thomas Shoal and similar territories in the South China Sea have implications for international law, notably the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), regional security, and the principle of freedom of navigation. They also reflect the broader strategic competition between China and the United States, with the latter frequently conducting freedom of navigation operations (FONOPs) to challenge excessive maritime claims.

5. What efforts are underway regarding the Second Thomas Shoal?
Diplomatic efforts to address the dispute over the Second Thomas Shoal include bilateral talks between China and the Philippines, as well as multilateral discussions within the framework of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN). These efforts aim to manage and de-escalate tensions, although significant challenges remain in reaching a lasting resolution.

6. What are the risks associated with the Second Thomas Shoal?
The main risks include the potential for military escalation, accidental confrontations, and the undermining of regional stability. The dispute also complicates efforts to manage and protect the marine environment in the South China Sea, given the area's ecological significance.

7. Future outlook on the Second Thomas Shoal dispute
The future of the Second Thomas Shoal dispute is uncertain, largely depending on the broader dynamics of the South China Sea disputes and relations between China, the Philippines, and other stakeholders. Continued diplomatic engagement, adherence to international law, and efforts to negotiate a Code of Conduct in the South China Sea are critical for peace and stability in the region.



Get a call back

Fill the below form to get free counselling for UPSC Civil Services exam preparation


Stagflation: Causes, Effects, and Economic Impact
Inflation Expectations in India:Simplifier
Opportunity Costs and Trade-offs:Simplifier
India's digital public infrastructure:Macroeconomic View
Global IT outage:Blue Screen of Death
Natural rate of interest in an economy
Enemy Property in India
Union Public Service Commission (UPSC):Indian Constitution