The Right to Recall (RTR) is a legal provision in some states of India that allows citizens to remove or replace public servants holding posts such as Sarpanch, Mukhiya, Corporator, and Mayor in the government. This mechanism is primarily implemented at the Panchayat level but is also seen at the municipal level in certain states.
States with Recall Laws at Panchayat Level
The Right to Recall has been implemented at the Panchayat level in the following states:
1. Uttar Pradesh
2. Uttarakhand
3. Bihar
4. Jharkhand
5. Madhya Pradesh
6. Chhattisgarh
7. Maharashtra
8. Himachal Pradesh
9. Punjab (since 1994, as a provision of no-confidence motion)
10. Haryana (recently passed for the Sarpanch)
Procedure for Recall of a Sarpanch
The procedure for recalling a Sarpanch involves two steps and can be initiated directly by citizens:
1. Initiation: After a lock-in period of 1–2 years (varying from state to state), a certain number of voters of the Gram Sabha must submit their signatures or thumbprints along with a petition to the Collector’s office.
2. Verification and Voting: After verifying the signatures, a meeting of all Gram Sabha members is organized. If the majority of the Gram Sabha votes against the sitting Sarpanch, the Sarpanch is removed from office.
States with Recall Laws at Municipal Level
The Right to Recall has also been implemented at the municipal level in the following states:
1. Accountability: Increases accountability of public servants as they can be removed by citizens if they fail to perform their duties effectively.
2. Empowerment: Empowers citizens to have a direct say in the functioning of local governance.
3. Transparency: Promotes transparency in governance by ensuring that elected officials remain answerable to the public.
Cons
1. Political Instability: Frequent use of recall provisions can lead to political instability and disrupt governance.
2. Misuse: The process can be misused for political vendettas and personal grievances rather than genuine accountability.
3. Administrative Burden: The recall process can be cumbersome and administratively challenging, involving significant time and resources.
Current Debates
There are ongoing debates and demands for the abolition of the Right to Recall in some regions. For instance, the Haryana Sarpanch Association is demanding its abolition, citing concerns over its misuse and the administrative burden it imposes.
The Right to Recall remains a significant but controversial tool in enhancing democratic accountability at the grassroots level in India.
SRIRAM’s
Share:
Get a call back
Fill the below form to get free counselling for UPSC Civil Services exam preparation
