Article 19 and the Reasonableness Doctrine

  Sep 01, 2023

Art.19 and the Concept of Reasonableness

Balancing Individual Rights and Society's Needs

Every democracy values individual rights. These rights protect personal freedoms and keep the government from overstepping its bounds. But, these rights have limits, especially when they clash with the greater good or others' rights. The Indian Constitution has a term called "reasonable restrictions" in Article 19 to manage this.

Understanding Reasonableness:

"Reasonableness" means being fair and logical. If a rule is called "reasonable", it's well-thought-out and doesn't unfairly limit personal freedoms.

How to Judge Reasonableness:

Purpose: Restrictions should have a clear and good reason, like keeping the peace or safeguarding the country.
Balance: The rules should only be as strict as they need to be. If a simpler rule can work, it's better to use that.
Fairness: The rules shouldn't unfairly target certain people or groups.
For Everyone's Good: Rules should help everyone in society, not just a few.
Right Way: How rules are made and used is important. They should be clear, fair, and allow for people to challenge them if needed.

Rights vs. Restrictions:

Rights are important, but sometimes they need limits. For example, people should be free to speak their mind, but not if they're encouraging violence.

Role of Courts:

Courts help decide if restrictions are "reasonable". They make sure the balance between personal rights and the greater good is right.

To Wrap Up:

"Reasonable restrictions" in the Indian Constitution help balance personal freedoms with society's needs. While the government can set some limits, they must be fair and logical. This balance helps democracy work well.


Get a call back

Fill the below form to get free counselling for UPSC Civil Services exam preparation


Shahpur Kandi Barrage and Water Allocation
Explainer:Selection of Astronauts for Gaganyaan Mission
Understanding the Household Consumption Expenditure Survey 2024
Obelisks: New Discoveries in Human Microbiomes
Discovering Obelisks: A New Form of Life
India’s Milestone: Completing the ‘10,000 Genome’ Project
Wildlife Conflicts in Western Ghats
NaMo Drone Didi Initiative
Dwarka: Unveiling History and Myth
Indian Gharial in Kaziranga
Benthic Predators: Masters of the Ocean Floor
Guitarfish in India: Conservation and Habitat
India's Water Crisis: A Challenge and Path Forward
Understanding “Woke”: A Brief History
Comprehensive Land Management Policies